Try Microsoft Bookings first if your firm already has an eligible Microsoft 365 plan and uses Outlook. Calendly is worth a closer look if you need more control over how meetings are shared among staff, or want a separate scheduling tool.

Both let people choose an appointment from a web page. The useful differences are what your firm already pays for, which calendars the tool checks and how it chooses the person who gets the meeting.

We write for personal injury firm owners and staff. This comparison uses the providers’ own pricing and help pages, checked October 30, 2026. We have not run a side-by-side product test.

Start with your setup

Microsoft lists Bookings in plans including Microsoft 365 Business Basic, Business Standard and Business Premium. It is not sold as a standalone app. Outlook on the web must be enabled, and your admin can limit access. Ask your admin to check your actual licenses before buying another tool. Bookings subscription guide.

Also choose the right kind of booking page. Microsoft’s Personal Bookings is for meetings with one person. Shared Bookings manages appointments for a team. A link to one attorney’s personal page will not give visitors the whole firm’s availability. Personal and shared pages.

Calendly can also check an Outlook calendar. Using Outlook does not force you to use Bookings. The choice is whether the separate service adds something your team needs. Calendly’s Outlook guide.

Choose who gets booked

First decide whether visitors should pick an attorney, meet with several people together or take the next opening with anyone on a small team.

Calendly calls the staff member holding a meeting a host. In Bookings, a service is an appointment type, such as a 20-minute first conversation.

Your firm’s need Calendly Microsoft Bookings
Book one named attorney Use that person’s booking link. Use a personal page or a shared service with that person assigned.
Book with any available team member Round Robin, on Teams and higher plans, rotates meetings among hosts. A shared service can assign one of the selected staff.
Control how meetings are shared Choose availability first or a more even spread of Round Robin meetings. Microsoft’s FAQ describes random assignment among available staff, without a guarantee of equal totals.
Require several staff together A collective event checks when the hosts can meet together. A service can assign all selected staff to the appointment.

See Calendly’s event types and Round Robin rules, plus Microsoft’s service types and assignment FAQ.

More openings and a more even workload are different goals. Calendly’s equal-distribution option can hide a busy teammate’s available times until others catch up. That can leave fewer times for visitors to choose. Try the rule your firm actually wants, rather than judging a calendar by the number of open slots alone.

Compare the yearly cost

Calendly’s US-dollar pricing shows Standard at $10 per seat per month and Teams at $16, with yearly billing. The person hosting meetings needs a seat; the visitor booking one does not. A simple individual page may fit the Free plan. Automatic Round Robin is a Teams feature, so do not choose Standard expecting it.

Suppose your firm has three meeting hosts:

Scheduling choice Example yearly cost
Three Calendly Standard seats 3 x $10 x 12 = $360
Three Calendly Teams seats 3 x $16 x 12 = $576
Bookings with three existing, eligible Microsoft licenses No added Bookings subscription; the Microsoft plan is still paid

The Calendly examples use the listed base plans, before tax or optional extras. They exclude Notetaker and Callie add-ons. If you need new Microsoft licenses, include their full cost. These are different bundles, so compare what your firm would actually add to its current bill.

Follow one booking

Consider Big Apple Personal Injury, a fictional firm with three attorneys: Avery, Jordan and Taylor. All three already use Outlook through an eligible Microsoft 365 plan. The firm wants visitors to book a 20-minute first conversation with any available attorney.

Maya tries to book Monday at 9 a.m. Avery already has a busy appointment then. Jordan and Taylor are free.

Example · Check one appointment

Service
First conversation · 20 minutes · one attorney
Monday at 9 a.m.
Avery is busy; Jordan and Taylor are available
Expected booking
One available attorney gets Maya's appointment
Staff check
The assigned attorney has the event; Avery's busy time stays protected
A planning example, not a product screen or a test result.

Big Apple should try Shared Bookings first because its existing licenses may cover this job. If it needs a specific rotation rule that Bookings does not provide, compare Calendly Teams using the same calendars and appointment.

Check the busy calendars

Before a trial, ask your admin to approve the calendar connection and what visitor information will be collected. Use made-up visitor details for the test.

  1. Check each host’s calendar. For Big Apple, Avery’s 9 a.m. appointment must be marked busy in the calendar being checked. An event saved somewhere else cannot protect that time.
  2. In Calendly, check both calendar choices. Open Settings > Scheduling > Calendars. Under Calendars to check for conflicts, include the calendar holding Avery’s appointment. Under Calendar to add events to, choose where new bookings should go. These settings do different jobs. Outlook connection steps.
  3. In Bookings, check each staff member. Keep Events on Microsoft 365 calendar affect availability selected. Microsoft says staff outside your organization can receive booking emails but cannot share free/busy data with Bookings. Staff calendar settings.
  4. Limit the staff pool. Include only the attorneys who should receive this appointment. For a Calendly team Round Robin, review the Hosts pool and distribution method. For Bookings, review the service’s Assign staff choice. Use “any” when one attorney is needed, rather than “all.” Calendly team setup, Bookings staff assignment.

If Calendly shows Approval required, ask your admin to approve the connection. Do not work around it with a personal account.

Try the visitor’s side

Now follow Maya’s appointment from booking to a changed time:

  1. Open the visitor page. Check it from a device or browser where you are not signed in as the owner. Make sure the intended outside visitors can reach it.
  2. Book the 9 a.m. test. Check the selected time zone and meeting length. Open the confirmation and the assigned attorney’s calendar. The time and meeting details should agree.
  3. Check the host, not just the slot. A pooled page may still offer 9 a.m. because another attorney is free. That alone is not a double booking. Check that the same attorney has not been assigned two overlapping meetings.
  4. Move the appointment. Use the booking’s rescheduling controls. Check the new confirmation, old calendar event and assigned attorney. Calendly Round Robin can reassign the host when a meeting moves; choose the setting your firm wants. Rescheduling rules.
  5. Cancel the test. Confirm that the appointment is cancelled in the scheduling tool and the staff calendar. Microsoft says Bookings appointments must be edited through Bookings, rather than directly in Outlook. Bookings appointment FAQ.

Also check the questions on the visitor page. Ask only what staff need to arrange the meeting. Keep detailed injury histories and document uploads in your firm’s approved intake process. A confirmed time should match the appointment your firm has agreed to offer.

Choose after the test

For Big Apple, Bookings is the sensible first trial. Its three existing Microsoft licenses may already cover a shared calendar with one available attorney per visit.

Calendly Teams earns the extra cost if its assignment rules or separate scheduling tools solve a problem the firm can show in that trial. If individual links are enough, test a simpler plan before paying for team rotation.

Choose after staff can follow one booking, a changed time and a cancellation without cleaning up conflicting calendars. For other software purchases, our PI AI buying guide uses the same idea: pick a job, then check the finished work.