Start with the person who will build and fix your forms. Gavel Workflows pairs questions built in a browser with Word or fillable PDF templates. HotDocs Advance uses a desktop tool called Author to build templates, then lets staff answer questions in a browser.
Both can turn one set of answers into several documents. Gavel calls its set of questions and templates a workflow. The useful test is whether your team can keep those documents right when a name, a fact or your firm’s wording changes.
If you already have working HotDocs templates, test them before paying to rebuild them. If you are starting fresh, bring the same small set of forms to each demo.
Pick who builds forms
There are two jobs: making the forms and using them. A person who answers questions each day may need a different license and setup from the person who changes the questions.
Gavel’s editor builds the questions in a browser. Its Document Tagger add-in puts named placeholders into Word files. A placeholder marks where an answer, such as the client’s name, will go. Its PDF Tagger connects answers to fields already in a fillable PDF.
HotDocs Author provides Word tools for building templates and their rules. The published Author requirements list Windows and supported desktop Word versions. Confirm the form builder’s exact computer and Word version. The people using the browser questionnaire have a different job and setup.
| Your question | Gavel Workflows | HotDocs Advance |
|---|---|---|
| Who makes the questions? | A Builder or Admin uses the browser editor. | A template author builds the questions and rules in Author. |
| Where do Word answers go? | Named tags in your Word template, added with Document Tagger. | Fields in your Word template, prepared with Author. |
| How do staff correct answers? | Open the saved session in Data Manager, change answers and generate new files. | Reopen the saved work item, change answers and assemble new files. |
| What about an existing PDF? | Map its fillable fields with PDF Tagger; the page layout stays fixed. | Have the vendor show your exact form. Generating a PDF from Word and filling an existing PDF are different tasks. |
For Gavel, check the user roles. A Builder can edit forms. An Organizational User can run assigned forms again and work with saved answers, but cannot edit the form itself. Check which roles and access your quote includes.
For HotDocs, have the quote name the Author licenses, staff access and hosted Advance setup you will use. A browser demo alone does not tell you what the form builder needs.
Bring one small packet
We’ll use Big Apple Personal Injury, an invented firm. Jordan builds its forms. Avery, an attorney, approves the wording and also needs to edit the forms. Three other staff members will use the questions to make documents.
The firm wants three files from the same answers: a Word cover letter, a Word case summary and a fillable PDF client sheet.
Example · One packet to try
- Client
- Maya Reed
- Incident date
- October 12, 2026
- Other party
- Lee Park
- Work missed?
- Yes; include the firm's approved work-loss paragraph
- Files needed
- Cover letter, case summary and client sheet
Bring blank copies of the firm’s forms and a short list of rules. Use invented facts for the demo. Avery chooses the wording and which answers control it; the software’s job is to apply those choices.
Gavel can connect several templates to one questionnaire. HotDocs also uses an interview, its name for the questions that collect answers for one or more documents. Ask each vendor to show the whole packet, including the PDF, before judging the result.
Try the same changes
Use this order in both demos. Keep the resulting files so staff can compare them afterward.
- Make the first packet. Enter Maya’s details once. Open all three files and check the name, date and other party wherever they appear. Check page breaks and any text that runs past a PDF field.
- Correct the name. Change “Maya Reed” to “Maya Reid” in the saved answers. Generate the packet again. The new files should use Reid throughout. A correction made only in one downloaded Word file does not show that the saved answers changed.
- Change a yes to no. Set “Work missed?” to No. The work-loss paragraph should disappear from the new case summary. Check for a leftover heading, empty line or broken numbering. Gavel’s paragraph rules address this kind of change. Have HotDocs show the same result using its template rules.
- Add another party. Add Rowan Gray beside Lee Park. Check that both appear in the Word case summary. Then look at the PDF: does it have enough rows for both names? Try a third party too, so you can see what happens when the rows run out.
- Change the firm’s wording. Have Avery replace “Please call Jordan” with “Please call Avery” in the cover-letter template. Run the packet again from the saved answers. Check the new sentence and confirm that the client’s name is still Maya Reid.
Gavel’s PDF guide states a useful limit: it cannot add rows or pages to a PDF as it can in a Word document. Big Apple’s PDF needs enough fields or an agreed extra sheet. Do not mistake a longer Word list for proof that a fixed PDF will fit it.
A successful demo ends with usable files after each change. It also shows who can fix a mistake without waiting for someone outside the firm.
Keep answers for later
Suppose Maya later corrects the incident date from October 12 to October 13. Staff need to find her answers, change the date and make a new packet without starting over.
Gavel’s Data Manager supports that path. Open the existing session, edit the answers and continue through the workflow to generate new documents. Confirm that the staff roles in your plan can reach those saved sessions.
In HotDocs, use a saved work item for this test. It holds the task and its answers so staff can return later. A quick document is different: HotDocs says it does not create a lasting work item and cannot be reopened. Its interview guide explains both choices.
Keep the new packet apart from old downloads. Check which version staff would send. Changing saved answers and generating new files does not tell you whether someone has already attached an older copy to an email.
Price the whole setup
Ask both vendors to price Big Apple’s actual team: two people who can edit forms and three who only run them. Name the three templates and the number of packets staff expect to make each month.
Get these items in writing:
- The licenses and roles each person needs.
- The plan limits for templates, saved answers and repeated use.
- The cost to build the first packet or move existing templates.
- Any Word licenses, hosting or support charged separately.
- Who pays when the firm needs a form changed later.
Use Gavel’s pricing page and HotDocs sales as starting points. The quote should cover the demo you just saw. A starting price alone does not price five people, form-building help and future edits.
If your firm has HotDocs templates already, include a few in the demo. Have the vendor identify which can be reused and which need work. Budget for moving the rules and checking the results, not just copying the visible text.
Choose after the demo
Put Gavel on your shortlist if its browser questions, Word tools and PDF field mapping fit the people who will build and maintain your forms. Put HotDocs Advance on it if its Author setup fits your team, especially when you have templates worth keeping.
Then let Jordan and one of the staff members who will use the tool repeat the changes themselves. Can they find the saved answers, fix the name and make the right packet? Can Avery change the firm’s wording? Compare that work with the full quote.
Keep the files from each change beside the written quote. Use them to choose a tool your team can keep up to date.
If those documents also need a client signature, our Docusign and Dropbox Sign comparison covers that next buying decision.