“Press 1 for a new case. Press 2 if you are an existing client.” If those choices help callers reach the right team, you may want to keep them. You can add an AI receptionist for new inquiries without making every caller start over.
A phone menu follows choices such as a keypad press or spoken answer. An AI receptionist can ask questions and collect the caller’s answers. Some phone systems can do both; what matters is the job each part does for your firm.
Here is how to decide what to keep, what to add and what to test. We’ll use Big Apple Personal Injury, a fictional firm, as the example.
1. Map your current menu
Open your phone provider’s menu settings, or ask the person who manages your phones for a copy. Write down each choice and where it sends the call. Twilio’s phone-menu guide explains how these paths work; your provider’s controls may differ.
For our example firm, the greeting might be:
Example greeting
- Press 1 · New case
- Speak with intake
- Press 2 · Existing client
- Reach the team handling your case
- Press 3 · Billing
- Ask about a bill
Next, call your firm’s number and try each choice. Does it reach the right person? What happens after closing time or when nobody answers? A clear menu is useful only if the path after it works.
2. Choose where conversation belongs
Use the Lighthouse customization walkthrough to see the questions an intake agent can ask.
For Big Apple Personal Injury, a new caller may need to describe an accident and injuries. An existing client may simply need their case team. Those calls do not need the same opening questions.
| What the caller needs | A simple menu | Lighthouse |
|---|---|---|
| Choose a department | Offers choices such as intake or billing. | Can ask why the person is calling. |
| Explain a possible new case | Sends the caller to the next person or step. | Asks your firm’s intake questions. |
| Speak with staff | Rings the destination for that choice. | Can try to transfer the caller to your chosen contact. |
| Leave useful details | Depends on the destination and phone system. | Saves intake fields, a summary and the transcript of the conversation it handles. |
This compares a simple department menu with Lighthouse. Advanced menu systems, often called IVR for interactive voice response, can also accept speech, gather information and connect to other software. Do not replace a system just because it uses a menu.
For our firm, the practical choice is to keep the existing-client and billing options, then add Lighthouse to the new-case path when intake staff are unavailable.
3. Set the call path
Open the call forwarding setup guide and find your phone provider. Confirm that it can send the menu’s new-case option to Lighthouse during the hours you want.
- Choose when Lighthouse should answer: all new-case calls, after hours, or when staff do not answer, depending on your provider’s options.
- Keep the other menu choices pointed at their intended teams.
- In Lighthouse, choose the daytime and after-hours contacts for calls that need a person. The customization guide shows those settings.
- Use a staff destination that will not forward the call straight back to Lighthouse.
At 9 p.m., our example could work like this:
Example · New-case call after hours
A caller chooses 1 and describes a car accident. Lighthouse asks about the accident, injuries and treatment using the firm’s questions. Staff can then review those answers to decide whether the case fits the firm’s process. A completed intake does not mean the firm has accepted the case.
4. Test before switching over
Use made-up caller details and arrange the test with your team. Check the full path before replacing your current setup.
- New case: Choose the intake option. Can the caller explain the situation and answer the firm’s questions?
- Existing client or billing: Try the other menu choices. Do they reach the intended team without a new-case interview?
- Staff available: Try a transfer. Does the right person receive the call?
- Staff unavailable: Repeat with nobody answering. What does the caller hear, where are the details saved, and who will call back?
- Saved record: Open the Lighthouse call. Check the intake fields and summary first, then the transcript if you need to confirm a detail.
Keep your provider’s instructions for restoring the old setup. Our forwarding and transfer guide explains the difference between sending calls to Lighthouse and connecting them back to staff.
Bring your current menu to a Lighthouse demo. Follow one call through before deciding which parts to keep.